Sunday, March 9, 2008

Blog #4


Chapter 3
1.
The concept of “true womanhood” came from the belief that men and women are completely opposite and that there is no similarities that cross between the two. The major components of “true womanhood” were that the women usually were not able to do anything that had to do with business, politics or jobs needing harsh labor. All the women were to do during the early nineteenth century was to take care of the family in the home while the men worked at their businesses. This was only true for the white families because if hard labor was needed to be done in the fields, it was usually performed by the slaves, regardless of gender. This ideology was very important for white men in America during the nineteenth century because they had seen it as a new class structure in which they would build their families. This allowed the building of the middle class families. It became a lot easier to create a middle class family when the men were working while the women were taking care of the children. Middle Class women began separating themselves from the poor by preaching that it was because of the lack of values women had for their families that made them poor.

2.The significance of the Lowell mill girls in the history of U.S. women is that it was a step in introducing women into their own independence without the practice of “true womanhood.” The girls that were working in these mills were young in age, usually in their teenage years. Women were finally able to receive their own wages through their labor which led to more possibilities that would rise for women. These girls moved out of their family’s farms and moved into boarding houses in the cities, where they would work and receive a maximum wage of two dollars a week for long periods of work. These girls would usually spend this money on themselves and were finally able to show that they were indeed able to support themselves and be independent. Eventually, there were problems with the unfair wages that were being paid to these women. These unfair wages inevitably led to a strike. Since it was the first time a women’s voice was heard loudly throughout Lowell, the strikes allowed for women to take a political stand on more issues in the future.



Source Interpretation
Textbook document ( Chapter 3 pp. 169-173) – “The History of Prostitution”
1. Sanger’s view was that women were not the ones who should be blamed for prostitution. He believed that men were at fault because they showed no concern for the pain that these women were enduring throughout their lives. Sanger also proved that these women that chose the life of prostitution were brought into the way of life do to their will to survive in the world. He also found that the women living in urban cities had to go through “financial pressures(169).” These women were also influenced into prostitution because most women, morally, would not live a public life of non marital sex (170).

2. After interviewing and analyzing the two thousand women, Sanger found that the top cause for the women going into prostitution was that they were poor and needed enough money in order to survive. They did not want to starve in the streets and prostitution was their ticket out. One girl could not stand watching her crippled sister suffering everyday, which is why she had gone into prostitution. It had ultimately become her only source of making money and she was unable to get out of it since nobody would give her another job. The women that go into prostitution develop a lot of problems mentally. They begin to feel as if they are unjust and begin to feel a lot of guilt.

3. During the study, Sanger does not blame the women for their choice of prostitution but instead gives us reasons for their choice. All the women who were interviewed had a reasonable motive. Many of the prostitute’s motives were that they needed enough money in order avoid starvation. The values that individuals had were usually ignored because surviving was their first priority. After reading the article, it seems that people did not have many values during the time in which Sanger lived because the women that went into prostitution were provoked by the harsh society that they lived in. Therefore, the values that are not taught to individuals in society will lead to individuals deviant behavior.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Tyler R #1

Hey Elias. Great job! I was having trouble with my writing my blog, but after reading yours I had a better understanding of the text. Thank you!

I can see a lot of similar reasons for prostitution as we do now. What do you think? I can never blame a prostitute for their ways because, as a woman, I think I understand. ( No, I'm not saying I am one) But I really doubt any women as a kid says "Hey I think I will be a prostitute when I grow up!" It is a life, yes, that they choose, but that is involuntary. Sanger's study proves the point, as you say. I am really glad that this study has been brought to our attention, but I think the public in our time needs to be aware of the problems that women face and why they become prostitutes.
It is unfair that we label everyone now a days. I think we need to put reason behind those labels. Maybe if our economy was not so harsh on women and gave them better opportunities this problem would not be so relevant today either.

gohar said...

Gohar R#2

Hi Tayler. Your R#1 part one was very short and you didn't describe anything from Elias great job. It was very good his great job gave you better understanding of what the text is about.

The part two of your writing was great. You saw the similar reasons for prostitution. You believe that is not their choose and there were to many causes. I'm agree with you and I believe the Sanger's study could be the warning for everybody. The government should think about them more accurate and more series.

Anonymous said...

Tyler's Response to Gohar
Well, thank you Gohar. Just one thing, it's a really big pet peeve of mine when people get my name wrong. I spelled it out in my blog so there shouldn't be any complications on how to spell or say it. If you have any trouble, feel free to ask me in class next week. The first part of my response was short. I know. I was just telling him he did a good job explaining the section and his work helped me out alot. It was not intended be long. So thanks for your response! See ya Tuesday!

Anonymous said...

Reena- R # 1

In response to Elias, I perceived that the purpose of the true womanhood gave women a better understanding of their role and more of a purpose to their traditional gender roles as a woman. Also, women were starting to have education institutionalized for better outcome at home. Also, I agree with Elias that the Lowell mill girls are significant because they represent an independence from their usual norm roles of women being at home all the time, these young factory girls worked for wages to support their families. Theses factory girls were the first females in the workforce that would change how society would look as a woman in the workforce. I agree with Elias on the points made from Sanger’s document on the Prostitution in New York. Sanger did not believe that we should blame the prostitutes, at that time, for any of their doings, but look at them as victims of their own society trying to hustle to make fast cash. Most of these women had crippled and sick relatives that they needed an opportunity to help their family members. Also, these women knew the power they had to use their bodies. They knew it would drive men crazy and easily get money. Brothels and other markets that promoted prostitution seemed to become a norm around the 1800’s.

annieg123 said...

Annie Response #1:
Great way of putting your answer for number one, I was having some difficulty with that. It is interesting to read about how women were being treated. Women did not work outside of their homes. The main idea for this era was to keep the middle class family going. Men were at work while women were doing the job at home. When the Lowell Mill girls opened up the business where women would stay and work at was an exciting start to prove women’s independence. Women enjoyed the fact that they were making their own wages. Even though, the job was not worthy, they were desperate for anything to cease their independence. Women were being given unfair wages. Which eventually lead to a strike, where women’s voice was being heard. Part II, was well said! It is true Sanger was not trying to point out the negative side of why women should not be doing prostitution and how they are doing it is wrong. Sanger was trying to get the reason and the behavior of women. What was causing them to get into prostitution? It came down to financial issues. Live was tough living in with out enough money? Women needed support and men were not able to help them out, so women had to seek money in their own way. Alcohol was another contributor many alcoholics hopeless and helpless turned to prostitution as well. It was a sad factor for women but they were being left with no choice. -Annie

Anonymous said...

Reena's R#2

In response to Tyler’s Response # 1, it is good that Tyler now better understands the material on prostitution from Elias’s blog answers. One can definitely learn and better understand the text from other peoples responses. Also, I do have to agree with Tyler in how the causes of prostitution are similar to the causes of why women get involved in being prostitutes. But I also think that there are more opportunities for women now than back then. I have known people who were as exotic dancers, and is not necessarily quite like a prostitute in the way of doing sexual favors, but many of them just want a few hours of fast cash. Some of them have to put some values aside like wearing a bikini and giving lap dances. And some of them do it because of abuse and abandonment. Also, I have to agree with Tyler that we can’t just put labels and look down on prostitutes from what we see in the facade. I’m sure each and every one of them have a story and not want many people to know because it may be the “other life” they are living just to help themselves economically.